For more information on why we think this list matters, please see out Why not LLMs? file.

Want to add, update, or remove a project listed below? Check out our Contributing Doc.

See a project on here that you love, and wish wasn’t on here? Check out our Guide for Removal and/or No AI Request Template.

Ready to fork a project to introduce a No AI policy? Check out our How to Slop Free Fork Guide.

Any other questions? Please check out our FAQ, and if your question isn’t answered there, please feel free to start a Discussion.

    • Telorand@reddthat.com
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      11
      arrow-down
      6
      ·
      23 hours ago

      Even if it does, what they are trying to do is admirable. The benefits of non-LLM code, specifically at this point in time, has multiple benefits:

      • Does not directly or indirectly support the normalization of billionaire-run models
      • Does not contribute to the systemic abuse of the poor and minority groups that often end up being neighbors with data centers
      • Does not contribute to the pollution these data centers generate.
      • Does not contribute to the cognitive decline of people who use LLMs (at least in their current form)

      “But it won’t ultimately matter” is not a valid reason to not do something. Value is not purely determined by the end result. And the idea that the list will continue to shrink presumes the inevitable ubiquity of LLMs; that’s not something anyone can predict at this point, including the billionaires and their shills, and it flies in the face of how the public feels about AI.

      What I suspect is this list will lose some members, sure, but it and others like it will be invaluable resources for quality codebases.

      • ☆ Yσɠƚԋσʂ ☆@lemmy.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        10
        arrow-down
        4
        ·
        21 hours ago

        This is the exact same mentality as trying to arrest the climate crisis by using paper straws. Not only does this accomplish nothing of value in the long term, it’s actually actively harmful because it gives people the feeling like they’re doing something which takes energy away from actually addressing the problems in a meaningful way.

        And the whole AI boycott movement is a great illustration of why people who don’t learn from history are doomed to repeat it. Back in the dawn of the Industrial Revolution, the Luddites were highly skilled workers who saw a few capitalists growing rich by introducing machinery to substitute for their own skill. And they set to work to burn the factories down because they thought that if they could only destroy the machines, the problem would be solved. They ultimately failed in their efforts because they failed to grasp the material forces driving the march of history. The machines prevailed because the ruling class wanted to cut costs and increase profits. The evils of the Industrial Revolution grew out of the possession of the means of production which grants the power to determine how technology is used. The same is true today, and it is why similar attempts to boycott AI are doomed to fail. Those who want to stop these systems from being put into production are merely attacking the symptoms of the underlying material relations.

        Attacking the machinery amount to barking at the wrong tree because it’s the class relations within which it happens to be applied that are the problem. As Marx put it, technology does not exist as an isolated phenomenon, but is dominated by the social structure of the society in which it happens to occur. To control the means of production collectively is to make technology serve human needs rather than merely increase the profits of the rich. That is the very lesson that the Luddites missed, and that many critics of AI are missing today as well.

        On top of all that, these companies are literally telling us what they fear most. They don’t care in the slightest that some niche community is going to make code artisanally. It doesn’t affect the overall dynamic in any way for them. Data centres are still going to be built, and the models will still be rented. What they fear are open models that people can run locally which the corps can’t control and that don’t have a moat. That’s what companies like Anthropic and OpenAI are trying to prevent right as we speak because that’s what directly hits their revenue streams and undermines their whole business model.

        If people genuinely cared about doing something useful they’d spend their time figuring out how to run models more efficiently, how to train them in a distributed fashion, and to lower the barriers for people running them locally. But instead we just get performative liberal brain rot as usual.