People have been jailed for things posted in 2012. So yeah, if you’re a smartass and edited Wikipedia, especially on subjects they want to control, it’s better to not remain in Russia, which is an easy thing to say.
From what I understood from other commenters, this has to do with the fact you could “take your post down”… this is however not the case for Wikipedia.
In 2022 it was still possible to leave Russia for its residents; about the only thing still distinguishing it from the Soviet Union. I wonder if that has changed meanwhile.
Of course there’s still the question of getting accepted as immigrant or asylum seeker elsewhere.
They try to give the appearance that leaving russia isn’t possible, but it very much is from what i’ve heard and it’s not particularly hard from the looks of it (outside of the fact that uprooting your life is always a hard task)
For WMF [Wikimedia Foundation] this means (i) Nobody may edit any Wikimedia project, first instance is a fine, second one is a criminal offense; (ii) If someone left anywhere in the internet any time a link to any Wikimedia project, and the link is still there, or was there for some time while WMF has been declared unwanted, this is again a fine, second time (another link I guess) is a criminal offense. If for example the link is on social media and the person who left it does not have access to the account it does not matter, it is an offense anyway. – Ymblanter
There is a “lasting” (длящееся) crime concept, that is seen as applicable towards potentially accessible internet posts and webpages. They are not treated as legacy media due to being 24/7 online, not printed/shown and done.
Just like if something is still hosted and shown, it is not unlike a physical public billboard that was posted somewhen ago and still advertises some idea to others. It may exist from the time when it wasn’t a crime, but if it becomes a crime AND still there, one get persecuted if anyone snitch on them or some agency detects them.
Old Facebook/Livejournal/VK/whatever posts dating back into the Land before Time are easy to understand from that pov. There already were minor prosecutions about past posts, but the major role was almost always played by current, after-the-law posts or actions.
What makes it more complicated is that these posts had personal or group authorship, and it was pretty easy to nail who is responsible for a personal account or a group page. While Wiki is just built different.
Let’s take a look at the page about Russia. Let’s suppose court is butthurt only about edits taking place after 2022, covering the ongoing warfare. Who of masses of editors are therefore guilty? The edits before 2022 are still in the page, the edits after too, the edits that happened after and only edited grammar and not put everything the court hates are there too. They all together form the webpage as it is now.
I don’t think any persecutor would care to figure out who edited what, and would just look for every editor of said page, everyone they can deanon and reach.
And if the whole foundation would be seen as hostile, then every editor of every page becomes a target, even if you are only editing math articles.
So, if you are in Russia and there is a way to edit/delete your personal/identifiable info from a Wiki account or put bullshit there, it should be done asap BEFORE it becomes a law. Wiki moders and admins should provide help with that, up to force anonimizing comment pages and contribution history. I don’t want my fellow nerds to get persecuted for editing and moderating wikis in their free time.
I myself had some media presence, but even before 2022, when they started to treat satanism and gayness as extremism, I scrubbed everything clear. I’m not going out for my silly posting. I won’t become a mere tick in someone’s monthly plan for persecution. That’s too cheap. And I try to keep being aware of what I post and how it can get back to me for as long as I’m still here.
The thing is, regarding your billboard comparison: the edits/contributions are one and done, Wikimedia Foundation is the entity that is continually serving the content, so using your logic they are the only ones responsible other than the people editing Wikipedia after a declaration of undesirability.
With independent journalists and their websites, like Meduza in the OP, our persecutors seeked both. I suppose they’d wrap the same model over the hell of wiki editing process. And slap everyone they can reach.
But is it retrospective or only if you continue editing articles after it were hypothetically considered undesirable?
There is a concept of “ongoing crime” which means that if you posted something in 2002 but it’s still online, you will be punished for it.
People have been jailed for things posted in 2012. So yeah, if you’re a smartass and edited Wikipedia, especially on subjects they want to control, it’s better to not remain in Russia, which is an easy thing to say.
From what I understood from other commenters, this has to do with the fact you could “take your post down”… this is however not the case for Wikipedia.
In 2022 it was still possible to leave Russia for its residents; about the only thing still distinguishing it from the Soviet Union. I wonder if that has changed meanwhile.
Of course there’s still the question of getting accepted as immigrant or asylum seeker elsewhere.
They try to give the appearance that leaving russia isn’t possible, but it very much is from what i’ve heard and it’s not particularly hard from the looks of it (outside of the fact that uprooting your life is always a hard task)
You know what’s NOT an easy thing to say, though?
Llanfairpwllgwyngyllgogerychwyrndrobwllllantysiliogogogoch
Bro is NOT reading the room
Still funny though
In principle it’s not restrospective, but also in practice it kind of is, at least according to this comment:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Village_pump_(WMF)#Office_of_Prosecutor-General_of_Russia_may_declare_WMF_an_"unwanted_organization"
There is a “lasting” (длящееся) crime concept, that is seen as applicable towards potentially accessible internet posts and webpages. They are not treated as legacy media due to being 24/7 online, not printed/shown and done.
Just like if something is still hosted and shown, it is not unlike a physical public billboard that was posted somewhen ago and still advertises some idea to others. It may exist from the time when it wasn’t a crime, but if it becomes a crime AND still there, one get persecuted if anyone snitch on them or some agency detects them.
Old Facebook/Livejournal/VK/whatever posts dating back into the Land before Time are easy to understand from that pov. There already were minor prosecutions about past posts, but the major role was almost always played by current, after-the-law posts or actions.
What makes it more complicated is that these posts had personal or group authorship, and it was pretty easy to nail who is responsible for a personal account or a group page. While Wiki is just built different.
Let’s take a look at the page about Russia. Let’s suppose court is butthurt only about edits taking place after 2022, covering the ongoing warfare. Who of masses of editors are therefore guilty? The edits before 2022 are still in the page, the edits after too, the edits that happened after and only edited grammar and not put everything the court hates are there too. They all together form the webpage as it is now.
I don’t think any persecutor would care to figure out who edited what, and would just look for every editor of said page, everyone they can deanon and reach.
And if the whole foundation would be seen as hostile, then every editor of every page becomes a target, even if you are only editing math articles.
So, if you are in Russia and there is a way to edit/delete your personal/identifiable info from a Wiki account or put bullshit there, it should be done asap BEFORE it becomes a law. Wiki moders and admins should provide help with that, up to force anonimizing comment pages and contribution history. I don’t want my fellow nerds to get persecuted for editing and moderating wikis in their free time.
I myself had some media presence, but even before 2022, when they started to treat satanism and gayness as extremism, I scrubbed everything clear. I’m not going out for my silly posting. I won’t become a mere tick in someone’s monthly plan for persecution. That’s too cheap. And I try to keep being aware of what I post and how it can get back to me for as long as I’m still here.
The thing is, regarding your billboard comparison: the edits/contributions are one and done, Wikimedia Foundation is the entity that is continually serving the content, so using your logic they are the only ones responsible other than the people editing Wikipedia after a declaration of undesirability.
With independent journalists and their websites, like Meduza in the OP, our persecutors seeked both. I suppose they’d wrap the same model over the hell of wiki editing process. And slap everyone they can reach.