Thou shalt not create a machine to counterfeit a human mind.

  • 0 Posts
  • 49 Comments
Joined 8 months ago
cake
Cake day: December 14th, 2024

help-circle


  • I disagree with the EFF and ALA on this one.

    These were entire sets of writing consumed and reworked into poor data without respecting the license to them.

    Honestly, I wouldn’t be surprised if copyright wasn’t the only thing to be the problem here, but intellectual property as well. In that case, EFF probably has an interest in that instead. Regardless, I really think it need to be brought through court.

    LLMs are harmful, full stop. Most other Machine Learning mechanisms use licensed data to train. In the case of software as a medical device, such as image analysis AI, that data is protected by HIPPA and special attention is already placed in order to utilize it.






  • I don’t. If it makes me a Luddite, I’m a Luddite.

    What doesn’t change is that this is a train heading toward a derailment at highspeed while on fire.

    Just today I had to walk through why GitHub copilot should not be used for security purposes. I explicitly told the engineer that a constructed url would be detected as a potential XSS vector by our vulnerability scans. They implemented several things, most of which did nothing. Finally, I grabbed the documentation on how to fix it, gave them the line number, gave them the function, and let them build and test it. It ran through the scans and of course it passed.

    I get the desire from leadership. I really do. But I’m more interested in our products not costing us more, especially when the LLMs are going to fail the economy on a wide scale.





  • It’s because we’re expensive. That’s the long and short of it.

    10 developers in Silicon Valley can run you $1-$2m in salary alone (it’s more expensive with benefits added).

    The industry constantly conspires to keep the salary of software engineers down. It does it cyclically too. In 2008 I was told I would have no problem getting a 6 figure job when I graduated by 2013. Of course the economy had other ideas. Same thing with the dot Com bubble.

    I currently make double what I did 10 years ago. It doesn’t actually matter much as inflation and a divorce has had my costs balloon just as much, but it’s still loads more than any other job out there.

    They’ll get what they want, one way or another. Then when none of their shit works they inevitably come back begging us and we request better pay and benefits again, because we know they do this. They don’t learn, much like those reliant on AI.