The domain https://fediverse.observer/ redirects to sedo now.
On October 11th these two commits where made to the repo:
this will be my final release, glad to have contributed since 2011 to some fediverse stats, https://fedidb.com/ is a great resource with more interest
this software is no longer developed
Sad to have lost such a great resource.


Blaze had calculated that at some point. It was quite awhile ago so that could have changed radically since then but… based on all of my personal experience things seem to mostly be moving in the opposite direction. e.g. as mander.xyz and slrpnk.net are both down (hopefully just temporarily), and smaller communities struggling mightily hence people remain in the biggest ones.
One example is !tenforward@lemmy.world retaining 5.77K MAUs compared to its offshoot !tenforward@piefed.world with just 0.08K MAUs. And I mentioned others like !nonpolitical_comics@piefed.social previously. You likely see this happening all across the entire Threadiverse. We cannot support much niche content so it generalizes instead. The trends towards centralization are not being counter-balanced as much as previously by trends away from that.
It does seem believable to me though, that separately from all MAUs, the number of existing communities that people post into are concentrated on LW. Again, there was a huge shift to try to spread them around, but that was before the Flotilla began threatening to split the Threadiverse in two in consolidation with anarchist.nexus, and I for one tend not to post into communities located on dbzero anymore (I am not like morally opposed to such, but I just don’t try to prioritize it as I once used to).
That is probably due to your having blocked a lot of it? But if you narrowly mean between AN & DB0 vs. LW then yeah to that much. Although I recall reading in the DB0 meta community that the call to defederate from LW was postponed: (1) for something like half to one year, for preemptively defederating then - i.e. this calming down period was intentional yet a vote as to whether to continue was still on the schedule even in the heat of it all, and also (2) separately from that, virtually a guarantee to happen if any single member of the Flotilla ever gets defederated from, I think this one not merely by LW but by any instance whatsoever, anywhere. That is no mere threat about some future vote that may or may not happen - that is outright policy, a settled matter, iirc.
Again, not that any of this stuff is easy to keep up with, even by us here, to say nothing of newcomers.
That assumption might not be true. If the Flotilla defederates not merely from LW but from any instance that remains federated with it, then the schism would be wide indeed. But we’d have to read more the Flotilla policy to see (again) their stated aims. I forget the likelihood of this being true, but it’s definitely nonzero and more than just a vague conspiracy theory - whether it actually happens or not, people were most definitely clamoring for exactly that to occur, and it was not a fringe opinion iirc. Then again, after the cooling period, things probably will look different, so most likely the most extremist opinions will be drowned out by those wanting the greater convenience of remaining connected.
I will now go read your post:-).
If there are multiple “active” communities of the same type on different instances, I tend to block .ml, .world, and .social communities (with the goal of helping de-centralization). So, I don’t have a good understanding of what an un-curated experience is like.
I think a more equitable comparison would be with !risa@lemmy.dbzer0.com, that has “2K Monthly Users”.
In the short term, I don’t see this as particularly problematic, as long as the communities are dispersed across instances (helps congregate activity / seem more active).
I take the opposite view of that event. I see the flotilla as protecting against an authoritarian action by the .world admins, in the same vein/idea as “Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.”. I have no faith the .world admins would have stopped at anarchist.nexus or would in the future.
Definitely possible. In a slightly related tangent, it looks like Piefed copied Pylova’s user block lists, but implemented them in an incompatible way. Also, possibly breaking instance conversion from Piefed to Pylova. Ugh…
My recollection is that defederation would only happen to instances that de-federated from a member of the flotilla (like .world). De-federating from anyone that federates with .world would be massive self sabotage (in my view). Hopefully, that’s not what happens.
Oh yes, the largest communities here are toxic shitholes. Politics, Memes, News, Comics, all are high contentious battlegrounds. Tbf the same is true and in fact far worse on Reddit, or was before the most heavy extremists were banned and now they are here instead of there anymore.
And if a new joiner came here and did not block as you did, they would have an extremely skewed perspective of this place. Numerically speaking though, it is your (and Blaze, and my) perspective that is different from the normal. Exception: PieFed.social bans all 3 of the tankie triad right away for new accounts, so that does significantly reduce that issue.
The history of TenForward was that the user Stamets had some drama with the !Risa@startrek.website mods and went off and started his own community, along with NegativeNull, ThePicardManeuver, and then Ummthatguy joined later, and then Stamets left and went off to make his own second Risa, !Risa@emmy.dbzer0.com. Anyway, if you look at the mod teams of the two TenForward communities that I mentioned, you will see that they are identical. So those two I would say are the most apt comparison - one is on Lemmy and the other on PieFed, but all other factors are the same.
Except one: TenForward on LW was the original community, and the PieFed one came along later, without much promotion from pretty much anyone that I’ve seen. There definitely is a strong effect whereby since the OG one is still present, and extremely highly active (one of the largest communities across the entire Threadiverse), that people stick with the OG one and have no need for the other. Especially when PieFed.World barely exists itself - see e.g. the paltry showing at https://piefed.world/topics, despite the multi-comnunity topic feed areas being one of the most popular features of the PieFed software platform.
There once was excitement that PieFed was going to overtake Lemmy. Now, even with v1.0 having been delayed for 18 months as you said, the excitement about PieFed is shrinking or already over. This here that exists now is pretty much what the Threadiverse will be for the next decade, as we continue to lose more people than we gain over time, and the software tools go into maintenance mode with a declining audience for their features offered.
Agreed - this is what must be, the only issue is that new joiners need to adjust to it, like communities don’t exist for specific games so much as just a gigantic “games” community, and at best perhaps an exceedingly generalized genre (but not finer-grained subgenres).
I was not trying to pass a moral judgement there, just stating it as almost a foregone conclusion that the Threadiverse is going to split. And then I added those details about who is going to cause it and why they said that they would. Also, the end result will be even fewer visitors to the Threadiverse, as even the upcoming tension that it might happen may already be affecting people’s recommendations as to what instances to join (regardless of whether or not it should happen or not, which I suppose mainly turns on whether the evidence was faked or not, which I admittedly haven’t bothered to examine as I see that point as irrelevant to the endpoint). Once again that increases the “complexity” required to be able to navigate this place.
Here we are free. This is no walled garden, or rather it is many gardens, or I prefer the analogy instead of free trader and pirate ships. The downside is that you leave behind “civilization” when you come here - there are no kings, not exactly, but there are fiefdoms, and you either need to learn how to self-host your own boat (which in today’s modern climate is hellish due to all the LLM scrapers ignoring all rules and traditions alike, presumably even targeting single-user instances), or learn how to navigate all of this complexity. i.e. there are responsibilities that come with this freedom.
None of which Reddit / X / Threads / Insta / Tiktok demands of them. So (most of them) will simply remain there.
User blocklists: I saw that they were added!:-) But not that they were incompatible:-(. Of all the petulance… :-|
Related to your personal blocking (me too ofc, as with most Lemmings): you tend to miss out on such gems as https://lemmy.ml/post/55085010/28894101 (link is to a comment but the entire post is illustrative as well), and also this post https://lemmy.ml/post/54724340?sort=Top - make sure to sort comments by Hot or Top and see especially (but not exclusively) the top one. Calls for literal murder tend to turn mainstream normies away. We are an extremist / tankie bar here, whether some of us block it out or not, numerically such posts remain and new joiners are extremely likely to stumble upon them. Especially if they pick Lemmy.ml as the flagship instance, which shows Local rather than All posts to a guest viewing without an account.
Every single person that I have mentioned the Lemmy platform to has outright chided me for telling them about it. We block, but new joiners don’t know how yet, and to them, the above pair of posts mostly exemplifies what this place is. An extremist place, highly opinionated, and not terribly welcoming to mainstream folk, who tend to be centrist, religious, and non-technical, unlike the prevailing trends here.
My block list is probably doing me many favors in regard to those.
Yeah, I think getting more instances to institute an initial user-level instance block for the “triad” instances (like .zip) may be the best return on effort, at this point.
I recalled the Star Trek communities splintered, but didn’t remember the specifics.
I think we might have been discussing different points. It seems, to me, you may have been talking about Lemmy vs. Piefed and I was talking about Plurality/Flag-ship instances vs not.
Yeah, not many people holding Piefed’s ‘water’ at this point.
I don’t know that we will still be like this in a decade, I still consider the Threadiverse to be at a ‘Beta’ version level (maybe ‘Alpha’). As bad as it may look at times, we aren’t losing users faster than we are gaining them, actually +3.8% compared to a year ago).
I like that you brought the games community up, it seems like that is the only area right now big enough to host a variety of more niche active communities (ex. tabletop, patient gamers). So, might be the closest to breaking out into more singular communities (ex. !cyberpunk2077@lemmy.world, but possibly GTA6 will be the first majorly active one, assuming it’s not already and I’ve blocked it).
I’m going to still disagree that, if it were to happen, it would not be the flotilla causing it. In my view, the entity causing the response is the responsible party (like if Russia invaded a Baltic country and NATO declared war on Russia, Russia would have caused the war, not NATO).
Possible I haven’t seen those discussions due to my blocks.
I like your analogy. Never heard of the “free trader and pirate ships” version (flotilla == pirate ships, I’d guess).
Well said.
Yep… :(
Yeah, my thoughts exactly. Plus breaking the Piefed -> Pylova conversion, seems to me Rimu is trying to wall his garden.
I was expecting much worse, based on what you were saying. I see where you’re coming from, but I don’t think posting or writing about a guillotine is that radical. I think most people don’t think the law works and isn’t likely to justice for the leaders/rich/whatever that are abusing/imprisoning/torturing/murdering/genociding people in broad daylight. So, not surprising to me they would call back to one of the well known times that those types of people got “justice”.
Another way you may want to consider is, what’s the difference between beating someone to death, starving them to death, poisoning to death (via tainted drinking water), withholding lifesaving medicine (ex. cancer treatment), or working someone to death. They all lead to death, usually just on different timelines and with different levels of direct interaction.
If a CEO jacks up the price of life saving medicine 1000% and now 10,000 people can no longer afford it and they die, did that CEO kill them? Some may say no, others may say yes. If the answer was yes, then if some random rich person is killing thousands a day/month/year/whatever, and the law will likely never touch them, what should someone do? If the only answer people give them is vote every other year, and hope that something that has never happened in their live happens, I don’t think many tempers will be quenched and people will search for and call for other solutions.
As in they checked it out and ran away screaming?
“religious” is an unexpected inclusion. I almost never run into anyone religious IRL or online. “centrist” is also a curious point, who’s “centrist” (American, European, Canadian, South Pacific, other; they are all different)? I think your environment may be affecting your viewpoint here.
Edit: New community you might want to check out: !blocklists@cozyver.se
Seems like. Although then they will make alts on places like LW, though still it would be something rather than the current nothing in terms of separation from ML.
https://web.archive.org/web/20240215044855/https://lemmy.world/post/11959030 - if you want the intricate details of Stamets creating TenForward. The story dates back to Reddit, goes through c/Risa@ST.W, and ends prior to him creating the second c/Risa@db0.
Sad but true.
In the back of my mind I was indeed thinking that the future may bring such. Though there are also an enormous slew of dead ones that people have to wade through as they search for what they like, which can cause confusion. Like !drpg@discuss.online - created by someone who literally never posted to it, just making 3 posts and 2 comments over the course of a year or two, then left us. I tried to help it out by making a really long post, but niche content just isn’t appreciated here, generally speaking.
Tbf along those lines there is a less niche version of that topic in !crpg@lemmy.world, though it looks to be carried mainly by a single poster. Until they burn out.
I see what you mean, but in that case everything there turns on whether the evidence was fabricated or not by the LW admins. I was taking Rimu at his word, also supported by screenshots iirc, plus the scenario seemed entirely believable to me. Likewise it has a consistency to it, e.g. the admin in question at AN refusing to apologize, nor DB0 either, though the former did step down. So lots of ego at play and nobody taking “responsibility”. And in the background, it seems to me that LW has a legitimate need to abide by the laws of whatever nation it is in - the right of someone else to speak should not impinge upon someone else’s rights to be forced to listen, nor even the rights of an instance to not have to platform such. Then again, that works both ways too, and the Flotilla has no obligation to platform LW communities either:-).
But all that was merely background, and does not begin to touch upon actual outright lies / disinformation on the part of LW admins. Do you have a link to where that was demonstrated? I sorta took the position, especially given the above background context, that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence - not just the word of an instance admin who said thus at the same time as they “voluntarily” stepped down (which could be just sour grapes / salt the earth as they leave?). But if that exists, then I would totally change my position on this.
Yet I still think it doesn’t quite matter, in terms of the downstream effects it would cause regardless. It would help to know whether they were fully justified or not. The burden of proof is also upon the ones doing the retaliation - e.g. Ukrainians took pictures of Russian atrocities, and had personal testimonials etc. - to explain themselves. So far they only explained it (that I saw) in tribal terms where LW allows content that describes genocide but then does not allow the reverse, bc the former while not latter is written in a “civil” manner.
The boat rather than email analogy is not mine - it is something I read on r/RedditAlternatives before I left during the Rexodus to join Kbin. That’s still a great resource to learn what people say about us here though - see e.g. https://www.reddit.com/r/RedditAlternatives/comments/14gg9ue/this_is_my_problem_with_lemmykbinfediverse_i_dont/ a 3 year old post highlighting (with screenshots) one of the very MANY reasons that mainstream non-technical normies have enormous troubles navigating Lemmy. Notably, Lemmy has done next to nothing about this problem iirc, still treating people that abandoned their accounts several years ago the same as those who are active in those communities today. But we’ve discussed before how PieFed has solved this ) onboarding) problem, before Rimu shot himself in the face and scared off his existing collaborators.
Thank you! It is good to hear both positive and negative feedback.
Oh yes totally. I think I shared earlier where a ML mod told someone in a game community to outright kill themselves, then doubled and even tripled down indicating a desire to shoot the recipient himself.
So: (1) these examples are by no means the worst-case scenarios. Rather, these are the more casual ones that I could find within about two minutes of searching. (2) For these (unlike the mod KYS scenario outlined above) I am not passing a value judgement, just stating what I perceive about how such produces a “culture shock”, which turns mainstream normies away from this place. They claim that this place represents a haven for extremists who routinely call for murder, and on ML this is true. I am not decrying ML’s right to exist, only saying that if people on the Threadiverse are truly serious about wanting this place to grow, then this extremism needs to be accounted for during the onboarding process. Ideally making it opt-in, as opposed to now where on Lemmy there is literally nothing that can be done about the situation, and on PieFed/PyLova (except PieFed.social now) it is opt-out instead.
Not merely that but literally chiding me with such a look on their faces!! Some people use Windows, rather than Lunux, Chrome instead of Firefox, are religious rather than atheist, etc. - there’s an entire world out there! As in, why would a Ukrainian feel like they want to come to this place that is constantly saying that it was their fault that Russia had to put them down, bc they were invading Russia rather than the other way around!? And in virtually all top-level communities too - Comics, Memes, News, etc. Oh, some additional pieces of information crucial to understanding this includes that: (1) for many years a Google (not DuckDuckGo, actual Google) search of “Lemmy” would to to Lemmy.ml, rather than like LW or a more neutral third-party site. (2) The default on ML is to show “Local” rather than “All” content. (3) There’s some other points of probably decreasing importance that nonetheless still play a role - like how communities suggested primarily favor the older ML instance rather than more active current ones, hence “Memes” = !memes@lemmy.ml.
People really seem to dislike all of that being thrown in their face. Read the comments on Reddit - when you do your onboarding analysis you’ll see. Make a poll maybe.
Religious/Centrist/etc.: aren’t the majority of Redditors Christians from the USA? And Muslims from the EU are also a strong secondary demographic. I said centrist bc even if an American thinks that they are a flaming red commie, that still puts them more or less solidly in the realm of centrist compared to people here. Or so I am lead to believe from the way that people talk here. But I could be wrong. And once again I’m not placing a value judgement - just saying that IF these people (i.e. current Redditors) are the ones that we want to encourage to come here, THEN we will have to make this place more welcoming to them first. And ngl, many Americans are outright conservatives - including very many content creators (Scott Adams of Dilbert fame springs to mind). It is very much doubtful that this place will ever go so far as to be welcoming to those people. Hence why I said “centrist”, which I meant to also imply liberal.
I hadn’t seen that - thank you! :-)
I suspect it would still be an improvement on the blanket acceptance they receive from the .ml admins.
Appreciate the linked breakdown. I may have read that at some point, but at best, forgot most of it. Was looking for the faked evidence post and found: Stamets’ post after moving to DB0 from LW and an update a month later.
Yeah, I like that threelonmusketeers@sh.itjust.works is trying to get the different dispersed community mods and active posters to congregate (example).
(April 27th) Here’s, surprisingly Stemets’, breakdown on the initial LW defederation of AN.
(April 29th) Yeah, the screenshots were shown to be doctored, with an active archive link to the supposed incriminating conversation that showed the conversation was doctored. My recollection is when asked for a response the .world admins just never responded or reiterated they were real and ignored the evidence.
That took forever to find. I thought it was in a deleted post were everyone was commenting on a Fediverse@LW post. Not sure what that one was about, but definitely part of all the arguments between LW + Rimu vs anarchist instances.
(May 4th) Looks like I forgot about the “Proof of AI-assisted political profiling by Unruffled @ lemmy.dbzer0.com” charge (by Rimu). Post has been deleted on Fediverse@PS. Here DB0 refutes Rimu (most of the way down that page of comments). I don’t want to re-read all about that drama, so take my recollection with salt and dive into the linked post if you’re curious. My recollection is one of the DB0 mods was trying out a llm user ‘evaluator’ and Rimu went with every DB0 mod and admin is using it. I am very much against the idea of an LLM moderator, but it wasn’t all of DB0 it was one person trying it out. Side note, I do recall them trying it out on Rimu. They deleted the comment and link later, but I followed the link before deletion. Don’t recall what it said though. I think maybe just that he was a neo-liberal and not a Zionist, but that is me reaching for a memory, so lots of salt on any specifics.
Interesting read. I wonder if a automated “purge” of inactive communities (no posts in ~2 years) would help solve the “dozens of the same community problem”.
Checked out the community and there is a post from yesterday. Seems like fertile ground (“Federation, FOSS”, “To speak only with other human beings”, with good on-boarding: “More actual discussion and less hate mongering.”, “Old reddit from about 7 or 8 years ago, in terms of appearance, operation, and overall character …”).
Not surprising, and I suppose that’s your point.
It’s been a long time now since I visited Reddit, but I think the more shocking thing to a new user, wouldn’t be that someone made the comment, but that no-one removed it. The Fediverse/Threadiverse doesn’t have corporate owners trying to maximize their stock price. So, as long as users aren’t advocating for violence against other users (as in your ML mod point) or specific people IRL, I don’t really see a problem (ex. a random vent against the abstract rich and corrupt is fine by me).
I hear elderly neo-liberal people IRL advocate for extrajudicial killing of politicians, regularly. Of course they also are abhorred by violence against CEOs and the rich so, they seem to mostly be okay against anyone they don’t like (not a great moral barometer).
Absolutely.
I enjoyed that visual. Thank you :)
Yeah, what I see is the opposite, but I suspect that is my block list doing good work :)
Looks like it’s better now (Start-page 3rd result: join-lemmy.org, 6th result: lemmy.world, 48th result: join-lemmy again).
Not overly surprising to me. Authoritarians like to keep their narratives intact.
Looks like they rank based on “Total Subscribers” rather than “Active”. That seems like a do-able fix, probably help communities stay alive too (new users going to the most active community).
Not sure when that analysis is going to happen. I’m still kicking around how I would even get the data. I could apply to each instance (time consuming and potentially dox my location). I could message all the admins a message, but would they have the time or interest to respond. I think unverified users taking polls would skew the data. I don’t really know, yet, a good way to go forward. Let me know if you have any insights.
I would have gone the other way on Reddit, with most being atheists (I believe it was one of the first communities and one of the biggest for like a decade). Never heard about “Muslims from the EU” being a thing. I stopped using Reddit years ago, so maybe that’s new.
My understanding is American Centrist/Neo-liberal position is right-wing in Europe (possibly only “Western Europe”).
I see your point. I think a blanket user-level “politics” block list would do the job well enough. I block almost all the meme communities, so not sure if those are “problematic”, but you listed them (“… in virtually all top-level communities too - Comics, Memes, News, etc.”), so probably them too.
I don’t know. I think lemmy.world is probably a good fit for neo-liberal Reddit refugees.
True dat.
OOOH, Stamets, right. To explain why I missed it: Stamets not only is an absolute ass, he also strikes me as very untrustworthy. I don’t recall the previous fight between Rimu vs. the entire rest of the world before that LW vs. AN matter (I think it had something to do with bots? later I am adding: YES, I think it might have been that AI-assisted modding thing!), but he seemed to me to be willfully disregarding all of the facts, even as he seemed like he was advocating for the common man but doing a very poor job of it. I 100% do not mind if someone says like “I can’t quite put my finger on it, but I dislike this person (Rimu)” - I can handle vagueness and imprecision - but to be presented with facts and figures and screenshots and evidence and not respond to any of that but double-down all the harder on the points that have already been disproven, strikes me as very poor form. Like even a stopped watch is right twice a day, and even Donald Trump can say a good thing, we don’t need to be tribal to oppose all the “other side” people, just the other side ideas that should be able to stand or fall entirely on their own merit (only resorting to tribal thinking as a tie-breaker or to save time). Also, Stamets was obviously going through something IRL at the time - I believe he said as much - as he left TenForward, the very community that he himself had created. Eventually he created the second Risa, but that was not the reason that he left.
That said, while I would very much distrust any conclusion that he would arrive at (especially around that time-period while he went through whatever IRL), I also would highly doubt that he would willfully make up false facts like screenshots. So I am not calling him a liar, just stating my previous bias to explain why I missed whatever evidence he presented. I had already mentally checked out of his messages by that point. How weird would it be if he was right, and just did not manage to convey that in a manner that I was receptive too, because of that prior matter (AI modding).
Thanks for the links - I have not yet but I will read them. Archived data that has since been changed is fairly damning. This is one of the MAJOR reasons that people defederated from Hexbear, not only b/c it exists primarily to troll other users, but b/c the admins were caught lying to other admins. Whoever did the lying should be removed as an admin - do you know why they have not been? LW tends to be slow, but over time they do seem to care about this stuff, so I wonder why not? Or is Russian disinformation coming into play - some archival sites themselves have been shown to alter past data! I am not that deep into the admin drama.
And really I am not even so much “pushing” that we need to grow the Threadiverse - just stating that if we wanted to, they would likely come from Reddit, and be turned off by all of the enormous complexity, just like most of us here are also turned off by it, even though we who have been here longer know how to navigate around it.
I don’t like that idea - first off it discards data, which may have answers that someone would like to read later on (e.g. how to fix something, or a funny meme picture, or like an analysis of a current event as it is happening, which can be different than the event viewed with hindsight, etc.). Also, it still leaves the “problem” active for multiple years before “solving” it. (and I could go on, like a single post in a 2-year period could prevent that community from going away, plus I recall an occurrence where 196 moved from LW to Blahaj but while >90% of the people moved, a handful did decide to stay - so in that case the community would not be entirely purged, and to state that it is the most popular community with that name would be highly misleading, in that while that once was true, after the migration it is no longer true, so misleading and outdated data).
That said, the issue where on Lemmy communities are sorted by lifetime number of members is absolutely already solved by PieFed/PyLova (I almost want to reverse the ordering of those two, but I suppose PieFed was historically first:-), since it uses MAUs. However many tens of thousands of users a community might once have had 3 years ago does not matter in the slightest if the last post was from over a year ago - MAUs are by far the best way to sort communities by current activity levels, even (especially?) if that would prioritize LW comms over ML ones.
Oh yes, they absolutely hate Reddit over there, on r/RedditAlternatives. That said, they despise Lemmy even more. Our reputation is really, shockingly poor, outside of this space.
You can read more about Reddit demographics, but a few key highlights are:
Also, in https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/1ib7py7/oc_reddit_user_demographics_vs_other_social_media/ you can see that more than any other social media platform (Facebook, Instagram, Tiktok, X/Twitter), Reddit leans left. Though as we agree, that means right.
And yes, Reddit is more atheist than it is religious, I believe you are correct there. But also, it is more religious than here, by far. Xhitter even more so, and especially Instagram & Facebook even more still. Just by virtue of being American, many Redditors are going to have a more religious background (as too I would think are most Hispanic cultures?). Remember the bias that the squeaky wheel gets noticed more - atheists are very ah… uh… “outspoken”. This does not (in itself) equate to any kind of either moral or numerical superiority. Anyway, if the Threadiverse wants to grow our subscribers, those people would have to come from somewhere.
Like here is a good back-and-forth conversation about the topic: https://www.reddit.com/r/RedditAlternatives/comments/1xk7z2v/comment/19rxs9tkgla4h/.
So I am not saying that the Flotilla does not have good reasons to defed from LW - damn, admins lying to admins sounds like a great one to me. “the reality is that a fragmented model cannot work” is the most common refrain I read on there, whenever I look. It’s too complicated, it’s too hard to find content (solved by PieFed, but that too is a complication, like already it’s not “Lemmy” anymore but rather part of the “and the sort”, like what is this PieFed vs. PyLova vs. Mbin concept and why should I care?, I could well imagine them asking), and basically every single topic is highly politically charged (again - no value judgement there, events irl are thus charged!!:-D though Americans are used to sleeping through such, and it’s a shocking awakening conversion process) and trolls run rampant. YOU and I have blocked them, but to a new account, they are not blocked by the vast majority of instance admins. Ironically LW does this a lot, whereas db0 does much less. To each according to their need I suppose…
Here’s a comment that says the above outright
Another highly relevant comment:
Of course this is the cache-22 - we cannot get new members until we first get new members. Which again, have to come from somewhere. Except we keep chasing them away rather than retaining them - as evidenced by the fact that we used to have 65K members, or at least we maintained a 40-45K steady state for a long time, until people simply gave up.
And there’s just so much more like that. Here’s an interesting comment:
And… I am out of space to continue to write anymore text, having hit the limi
No idea. I just know his summary matched my recollection of events.
I had one of those experience with Rimu, about data analysis. I laid out why he couldn’t make the claims he was making and he doubled-down and stuck his head in the sand. I try not to interact with his comments or posts now (no need to start drama where none exists).
No idea. I just linked his Star Trek updates, because I found them on while searching for the doctored evidence.
To be clear, Stamets is not the one making the claim the evidence is doctored (he just had a summary of interactions before that point in time), Loco_Mex@sh.itjust.works was posting the evidence.
I think that’s actually pretty common. In my experience, most people only take information from “trusted” sources. If you already distrust someone, it likely doesn’t matter what they say or how they say it.
Did not know that. Not overly surprising though.
No idea. Looking through all those past posts and comments, I recall seeing that the LW admins wouldn’t make decisions on removing power-abusive mods and tried to get others to do it. So, I wouldn’t hold out hope they ever did anything.
My recollection of that archival site was that it was using visiting users to DDOS-ing select websites. I don’t know of any falsifying of data/pages/pictures/etc.
Gotcha.
Fair points and it does seem like Piefed/Pylova have solved it with active users. I was using some Lemmy instances to search for the doctored evidence, so that was my frame of reference for the “search” functionality.
I know the feeling. I try to keep all my posts and comments neutral so nothing comes off biased, but I do try to add Pylova into any of my posts or comments about Threadiverse, so it has more exposure.
Haha. Not overly surprising, or counter to my understanding of the situation.
Thanks for the data source, some good stuff in there.
Interestingly, it looks like most of the data links eventually source to Statista, I can’t see their numbers without paying, but their graphs appear to visually show Reddit users decreasing in 2026, over 2025. It would be great to get the raw data to look at it in more detail, but oh well.
I think someone tried to make a christian instance. I blocked it quickly, but it may still exist.
Yep, I think this is back to ‘our on-boarding process is a failure and needs major improvements’ realm.
From what I’ve seen, most growth is in spikes (large increases and then significant decreases). So, relatively speaking, only dropping 30-40% from an all time max is actually really good (Mastodon is currently -73.0%). I think Loops is a really good example of what bad looks like (~29k -> ~4k, -86.3%). My generalization, from what I’ve seen, is 0 -> -25% is growing, -25 -> -80% is ‘stable’, and > -80% is ‘dying’. Not to say something ‘dying’ can’t come back to live, just that they are not in a good place and they haven’t been for a while.